Q.01

How do I check whether a cosmetic ingredient is restricted in the EU?

To check an ingredient, look it up in Annexes II to VI of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 (the EU Cosmetics Regulation), using the current consolidated text. Then check whether it has a harmonised CMR classification under CLP Annex VI, because Article 15 bans CMR substances separately from the annexes. If you give me the INCI name, CAS or EC number, I can run the whole check.

Approach: I read the current consolidated Cosmetics Regulation (consolidation 02009R1223-20260518), Articles 14, 15 and 17 and sample Annex entries.

Step 1: Search the annexes by CAS or EC number, not only by name. Article 14(1) says cosmetic products "shall not contain" any of the following [1]:

AnnexWhat it does
IIProhibited substances: a listing means the substance is banned
IIIRestricted substances: allowed only within the listed restrictions
IVColorants: a "positive list", so a colorant not listed is not allowed
VPreservatives: positive list
VIUV filters: positive list

For Annexes IV to VI, a substance that is listed but used for some other purpose still has to meet that Annex's conditions (Article 14(1)(c)(ii), (d)(ii) and (e)(ii)).

A name search can match the wrong entry. For example, searching "salicylic acid" also returns Annex II entry 1266, which is an azo dye with "salicylic acid" in its name [2]. That is why matching on CAS or EC number is safer.

Step 2: Read the whole entry, not just the fact that it is listed. The conditions sit in the entry itself. For example, salicylic acid's Annex V entry (reference 3) sets:

  • a maximum of 0.5 % (acid) in the ready-for-use preparation;
  • "Not to be used in products for children under 3 years of age" (with an exception for shampoos), and not in oral products;
  • a mandatory warning wording [3].

Entries list each salt and form separately, so check the exact form you use. One substance can also appear in more than one Annex.

Step 3: Check the CMR classification (Article 15). This applies to substances classified as CMR in Part 3 of CLP Annex VI [4]:

  • Category 2: use "shall be prohibited" unless the SCCS has evaluated the substance and found it safe.
  • Category 1A or 1B: use "shall be prohibited". The only exception is when all four conditions in Article 15(2)(a)-(d) are met, including no suitable alternatives and an SCCS finding that it is safe.

So an ingredient can be banned even before it appears in Annex II.

Step 4: Treat impurities separately (Article 17). A small, unintended trace of a prohibited substance "shall be permitted" only if it is technically unavoidable under good manufacturing practice and the product still meets Article 3 on safety [5].

Step 5: Look for changes on the way. Under Article 31, the Commission may amend Annexes II to VI after consulting the SCCS [6]. Pending SCCS opinions and amending acts with later application dates or sell-through periods can therefore change the answer soon.

Separately, the responsible person "shall" include the CAS or EC number of any CMR 1A/1B substance in the product notification under Article 13(1)(g) [7].

Q.02

How do I read a restricted ingredient entry?

An Annex III entry is a single row with nine lettered columns, a to i. Columns a to e tell you which substance the entry covers. Columns f to h set the restrictions, and they are linked by letter: each product type in f has its own limit in g and its own extra conditions in h. Column i gives the label warnings. Then read the footnotes, which can add sum-of-ratios rules, cross-references and transition dates.

Approach: I read the Annex III column headings, footnotes and a sample entry (hydrogen peroxide, reference 12) in the current consolidated Cosmetics Regulation (consolidation 02009R1223-20260518).

The column layout [8]

Col.HeadingHow to use it
aReference numberThe entry's ID, which is how other entries and Annexes refer to it
bChemical name/INNSets the legal scope; it can be wider or narrower than one CAS number
cName of Common Ingredients GlossaryThe INCI-type name
d / eCAS / EC numberSeveral numbers can be listed for one entry
fProduct type, body partsLists the uses the entry covers
gMaximum concentration in ready for use preparationThe limit in the finished product as used
hOtherFurther conditions: who may use it, age limits, purity
iWording of conditions of use and warningsThe label text that must be printed

Annex V (preservatives) uses the same a to i layout [9]. Annex IV (colorants) adds a "Colour" column, so it runs from a to j [10].

Worked example: hydrogen peroxide (Annex III, reference 12) [11]

  1. Scope (column b). The entry covers "Hydrogen peroxide and other compounds or mixtures that release hydrogen peroxide, including carbamide peroxide and zinc peroxide". It excludes the substances at Annex II Nos 1397, 1398 and 1399. So a substance can fall under this entry by what it releases, even if its CAS number differs from the 7722-84-1 shown in column d.
  2. Match each letter across columns f, g and h.
LetterProduct type (f)Limit (g)Other conditions (h)
(a)Hair products12 % H2O2 (40 volumes), present or releasednone listed
(b)Skin products4 % H2O2, present or releasednone listed
(c)Nail hardening products2 % H2O2, present or releasednone listed
(d)Oral products, including mouth rinse and toothpaste≤ 0,1 % H2O2, present or releasednone listed
(e)Tooth whitening or bleaching products> 0,1 % ≤ 6 % H2O2, present or releasedOnly sold to dental practitioners; first use of each cycle by a dental practitioner or under their direct supervision; not on persons under 18
(f)Products intended for eyelashes2 % H2O2, present or releasedFor professional use only

Watch the boundaries: oral products are capped at 0,1 % or less (≤ 0,1 %). Anything above 0,1 %, up to 6 %, falls under tooth-whitening row (e) and its dental-practitioner conditions. "Present or released" means you count both free H2O2 and any H2O2 released by the other ingredients. 3. Label warnings (column i). These are also keyed by letter. "Contains hydrogen peroxide", the eye-contact warnings and "Wear suitable gloves" apply to the product types listed against them. Row (e) must state the H2O2 concentration as a percentage. Row (f) has its own text "to be printed on the label".

Footnotes: read them every time [12][13][14]

  • Combined limits. Footnote (1): where several listed substances are used together, the sum of each one's level divided by its own maximum "does not exceed 1". Footnote (16) also caps the sum of substances used in combination.
  • What the limit is measured on. Footnote (15): "This limit applies to the substance and not to the finished cosmetic product". The hydroxide footnotes (4) and (5) express the amount as weight of sodium hydroxide.
  • Other entries for the same substance. For example, "For use as a preservative, see Annex V, No 3", or Annex III No 15a/15d for other uses of potassium hydroxide. The Annex V entry applies when the substance is used as a preservative.
  • Transition dates. These come in pairs: a "placed on the Union market" date (new stock) and a later "made available" date (stock already on the market). For example, footnote (46) gives 1 January 2027 and 1 July 2028. Some footnotes, such as (37) and (40), run the other way: they say non-compliant products "may" still be placed on the market until 31 July 2026 and made available until 31 July 2028.

Quick reading checklist

  1. Does column b cover your exact substance, salt or releaser, and does any Annex II exclusion apply?
  2. Which row in column f matches your product type and body part?
  3. Is your level in the ready-for-use product within column g for that row, with the boundary read exactly (≤, < or >)?
  4. Do you meet every condition in column h for that row (user group, age, professional use)?
  5. Is the column i warning text on your label for that row?
  6. Do any footnotes add a sum-of-ratios rule, an entry in another Annex, or a transition date?

If you send me a specific substance and product type, I can pull its entry and go through it row by row.

Q.03