Pesticide Residue Analysis Methods
Which methods are used for pesticide residue analysis in food?
Pesticide residues in food are measured mainly with multi-residue methods: a solvent extraction such as QuEChERS, followed by gas or liquid chromatography with mass spectrometry (GC-MS(/MS), LC-MS/MS or high-resolution MS). Single-residue or common-moiety methods are kept for analytes that multi-residue methods cannot handle. Regulators also set the validation, confirmation and quality-control rules that make a result usable for checking compliance with MRLs (maximum residue levels).
Approach: I searched the EU pesticide legislation (Regulation (EC) No 396/2005, the Official Controls Regulation, the data requirements in Regulation (EU) No 283/2013), the Commission's pesticide guidance register, EFSA Journal outputs, the FDA pesticide residue monitoring reports and Korea's MFDS residue test-method register. I also opened SANTE/2020/12830 and SANTE/11312/2021 v2 from their official sites. I could not open the Codex guideline CXG 90-2017 (its link redirects to the Codex home page), so Codex criteria are not covered.
1. The main techniques
Multi-residue methods (MRMs)
- EU: MRMs based on GC-MS(/MS) and/or HPLC-MS/MS "are routinely used in enforcement laboratories". Monitoring methods submitted for food "should be multi-residue methods", available from CEN, AOAC International or the EU Reference Laboratories (EURLs) (SANTE/2020/12830 Rev.2, §2.6).
- US: FDA analyses samples "with unknown pesticide treatment history" using MRMs that also detect many metabolites, impurities and alteration products [1].
Single-residue methods (SRMs) and common-moiety methods
- US: FDA uses SRMs for pesticides "not adequately extracted or detected using standard MRMs". They are more resource-intensive, so they are "employed more judiciously" [1].
- EU: for monitoring, SRMs "should only be provided if data show that multi-residue methods cannot be used". A common-moiety method may be acceptable if it complies with the residue definition. Gaseous residues (phosphane, sulfuryl fluoride, dazomet, metam) are given as examples that need headspace analysis (SANTE/2020/12830 §2.6–2.7).
Extraction and clean-up
- The EU guidance names "Modular QuEChERS" (CEN/TR 17063) and DFG S19 as standard modular multi-methods (SANTE/2020/12830 §3.8, §5.1.5). QuEChERS stands for "quick, easy, cheap, effective, rugged, and safe" [2].
- SANTE/11312/2021 v2 adds:
- adding water to low-moisture commodities before extraction;
- a hydrolysis step where esters or conjugates are in the residue definition;
- clean-up or dilution to reduce matrix interference;
- homogenising at low temperature where comminution degrades residues.
Instrumental determination
- Extracts are "normally analysed using capillary gas chromatography (GC) and/or high performance or ultra performance liquid chromatography (HPLC or UPLC) coupled to mass spectrometry" (SANTE/11312/2021 v2, C12).
- Analysers: single or triple quadrupole, ion trap, time-of-flight, Orbitrap.
- Ionisation: EI, CI, APCI, ESI.
- Acquisition: full scan, SIM, SRM/MRM.
- Classical detectors (GC: ECD, FPD, PFPD, NPD; LC: DAD, fluorescence) "offer only limited specificity" and do not give unambiguous identification (C13).
- EFSA's view: GC-MS suits volatile and semi-volatile compounds, though it may need derivatisation. LC-MS is preferred for polar, non-volatile and thermally labile compounds, and tandem MS improves selectivity [3].
"Commonly available" instruments for EU monitoring methods (SANTE/2020/12830 Table 1)
| Separation | Detectors |
|---|---|
| GC | FPD, NPD, ECD, FID, MS, MS/MS, high-resolution MS |
| HPLC/UPLC/IEC | DAD, UV, FLD, MS, MS/MS, high-resolution MS |
| None (elements) | AAS, ICP-MS, ICP-OES |
Supporting techniques
- Derivatisation for polar compounds or compounds that chromatograph poorly (§2.8).
- Chiral columns where a single enantiomer is in the residue definition (§2.10).
- Isotopically labelled internal standards (§2.5).
- Screening methods based on automated MS. A detection from a screening method "can only be tentatively reported" until a validated quantitative method confirms it (SANTE/11312 C45–C47).
2. Legal framework (EU)
- Article 28 of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005: methods "shall comply with the criteria set out in the relevant provisions of Community law relating to official controls". Official laboratories "shall participate in the Community proficiency tests" [4].
- Article 34 of the Official Controls Regulation (EU) 2017/625: where there are no Union method rules, laboratories use methods complying with internationally recognised protocols (including CEN) or EURL-recommended validated methods [5].
- Annex III of the same Regulation lists the criteria for characterising methods. They include trueness and precision, LOD, LOQ, recovery, selectivity, linearity and measurement uncertainty [6].
- Applicants (Regulation (EU) No 283/2013, point 4.2): methods with a full description "shall be submitted" for all components of the monitoring residue definition, so that Member States can determine MRL compliance in food and feed of plant and animal origin [7].
- Endorsed guidance: the Commission's register lists SANTE/2020/12830 as endorsed guidance for those method sections [8]. It sits alongside the extraction-efficiency guideline SANTE/2017/10632 [9] and OECD guidance on residue analytical methods [10].
3. Key performance criteria
For applicants' monitoring methods (SANTE/2020/12830 Rev.2)
- LOQ: generally 0.01 mg/kg, the default MRL, for plant and animal commodities.
- Matrix coverage, plant origin: validation in four matrix groups: high water, high acid, high oil, and dry (high protein/starch).
- Matrix coverage, animal origin: milk, eggs, muscle, fat, liver or kidney, and honey.
- Recovery and precision:
| Level | Mean recovery | RSD |
|---|---|---|
| ≤0.01 mg/kg | 60–120% | 30% |
| >0.01 to ≤0.1 mg/kg | 70–120% | 20% |
| >0.1 mg/kg | 70–110% | 15% (up to 1 mg/kg), 10% (above 1 mg/kg) |
- Matrix effects: significant if they exceed ±20%. Matrix-matched calibration is preferred.
- Confirmation: for example, at least one additional SRM transition in MS/MS.
- Independent laboratory validation (ILV): required for food and drinking water.
For official control laboratories (SANTE/11312/2021 v2, implemented by 1 January 2024)
- Validation: mean recovery 70–120% with RSDr ≤20%.
- Identification:
- retention time within ±0.1 min;
- MS/MS: 2 product ions with ion ratio within ±30%;
- high-resolution MS: 2 ions at ≤5 ppm mass accuracy.
- Routine recoveries: practical default range 60–140%.
- Confirmation: confirmatory analysis of another test portion "is required" when an MRL is numerically exceeded and legal action is possible.
- Quality assurance: proficiency tests are mandatory, and laboratories must be accredited to ISO/IEC 17025.
4. Other jurisdictions
- US: FDA's methods detect about 76% of pesticides with current or revoked EPA tolerances under 40 CFR Part 180, plus nearly 400 other residues [1]. Its default LOQ is 0.01 ppm, and detections between the LOD and the LOQ are reported as "trace" [11].
- South Korea: the MFDS register links each pesticide to an official test method.
- Several pesticides share one agricultural method number (7.1.2.2): chlorpyrifos [12], imidacloprid [13] and deltamethrin [14].
- Others have their own method numbers: glyphosate (7.1.2.14) [15], dithiocarbamates (7.1.2.11) [16], chlormequat (7.1.3.6) [17] and fosetyl-aluminium (7.1.3.46) [18].
- Ginseng has separate multi-component and single-component methods [19][20].
- The register gives only method numbers, so it does not show which techniques those methods use.
Sources:
Where can I find official pesticide residue testing methods?
Official pesticide residue methods come from four kinds of source. In the EU, they are the CEN standards and the EU Reference Laboratory (EURL) methods that the Official Controls Regulation points to, plus the Commission's guidance register. In the US, it is the FDA Pesticide Analytical Manual. In Korea and Japan, the food regulators publish the methods themselves: MFDS gives each pesticide an official method number, and Japan's MHLW issues methods by notification.
Approach: I searched the EU pesticide legislation, the Commission's pesticide guidance register, FDA's residue monitoring reports, Korea's MFDS residue test-method register, Japan's MHLW Positive List Q&A and MAFF registration guidance, and FAO/WHO pesticide guidance. The datasets don't hold the CEN standards or the methods published on the EURL portal themselves, and I didn't search the Codex methods texts this time.
EU
- Which methods official labs use (Article 34 of Regulation (EU) 2017/625):
- Methods "shall comply with Union rules establishing those methods or the performance criteria for those methods".
- Where no such Union rules exist, labs use methods that meet internationally recognised protocols, "including those that the European Committee for Standardisation (CEN) has accepted", or methods "developed or recommended by the European Union reference laboratories".
- Failing those, they use national-rule or national-reference-lab methods [5].
- Annex III of the same Regulation sets the criteria for characterising a method [6].
- Article 28 of Regulation (EC) No 396/2005: methods "shall comply" with the official-control criteria, and official labs "shall participate in the Community proficiency tests" [4].
- Commission pesticide guidance register (webgate.ec.europa.eu/dyna2/pgd/documents). These are the endorsed entries on analytical methods:
- SANTE/2020/12830, on analytical methods for risk assessment and post-approval monitoring [8]
- SANTE/2017/10632, on extraction efficiency [9]
- SANCO/3030/99, on generating and reporting methods under Regulations (EU) No 283/2013 and No 284/2013 [21]
- OECD Series on Pesticides No. 39, on residue analytical methods [10]
- EFSA's peer-review outcomes on recurring analytical-method issues, the latest dated September 2025 [22]
- EURL portal: the validation and quality-control document for official labs, SANTE/11312/2021 v2, is hosted there (opened in my previous answer): eurl-pesticides.eu.
United States (FDA)
- Methods manual: FDA cites its Pesticide Analytical Manual, Volume I, 3rd Ed. (https://www.fda.gov/media/74473/download).
- Validation guidance: FDA cites its Guidelines for the Validation of Chemical Methods in FDA Food, Feed, Cosmetics and Veterinary Products, 3rd Edition, 2019 (https://www.fda.gov/media/81810/download) [23].
- Methods in use (FY 2022): the multi-residue method covered 726 of the 757 chemicals analysed. Two single-residue methods covered the rest: one for glyphosate, glufosinate and their degradation products, and one for 27 acid herbicides. The report's Appendix A lists the chemicals each method covers [24].
South Korea (MFDS)
- The Food Safety Korea residue register links each pesticide to an official test method by number and link.
- Example: tritosulfuron and amidosulfuron both point to agricultural quantitative method 7.1.2.13 [25][26].
- Ginseng has its own separate methods (see my previous answer).
Japan (MHLW)
These points come from the 2006 Positive List System Q&A, a historical document.
- Notified methods and alternatives: test methods are given in MHLW notifications. A lab may use a different method if it performs as well or better on trueness, precision and limit of quantification and is shown to be specific (Q99) [27].
- Processed foods: there are no separate methods. Labs apply the methods for agricultural or livestock products (Q98) [28].
- Extraction: each method states its own extraction procedure. For tea, for example, it is either hot water or organic solvent (Q97) [29].
If you tell me which pesticide and commodity you're testing, I can look up the specific Korean method number, or the FDA method that covers it.