EPA Aquatic Life Criteria
What are EPA aquatic life criteria?
EPA aquatic life criteria are EPA's national recommended limits on pollutants in surface water. EPA defines them as "the highest concentration of specific pollutants or parameters in water that are not expected to pose a significant risk to the majority of species in a given environment," or a narrative statement that a water body should be "free from" certain harmful conditions (EPA aquatic life criteria table). They are recommendations, not binding limits: "State and Tribal governments may use these criteria or use them as guidance in developing their own" (same page).
Approach: I used EPA's national recommended water quality criteria tables (aquatic life, Appendices A and B) and Clean Water Act section 304(a) (33 U.S.C. 1314). I also read EPA's official aquatic life criteria web page.
Legal basis
- Under CWA §304(a)(1), the Administrator "shall develop and publish... (and from time to time thereafter revise) criteria for water quality accurately reflecting the latest scientific knowledge." This covers effects on "plankton, fish, shellfish, wildlife, plant life," and on "biological community diversity, productivity, and stability" [1].
- §304(a)(3) says the criteria "shall be issued to the States and shall be published in the Federal Register" [1].
How the table is set up
- Two exposure durations:
- The CMC (Criterion Maximum Concentration) covers acute, short-term exposure.
- The CCC (Criterion Continuous Concentration) covers chronic, long-term exposure (EPA).
- Separate freshwater and saltwater values. Example, alpha-endosulfan (2004-era values from 1980): freshwater CMC 0.22, CCC 0.056; saltwater CMC 0.034, CCC 0.0087 [2]. Most values are in µg/L (EPA).
- "(P)" marks a Clean Water Act priority pollutant, for example "Acrolein (P)": 3 µg/L for both freshwater CMC and CCC, published 2009 [3].
- Narrative and non-toxic parameters are included:
- Site-specific models replace single numbers for some metals:
- Adjustments for metals:
- Older criteria have caveats. Some entries still rest on 1980 methods, which predate the 1985 Guidelines. For an averaging-period evaluation, EPA says those acute values "should be divided by 2" to compare with a 1985-Guidelines CMC (aldrin, endosulfan) [10].
EPA publishes human health criteria in a separate table; they are not the same as the aquatic life values. I can pull the full aquatic life table or the values for a specific pollutant if you need them.
How do acute and chronic criteria differ?
The difference is the exposure each one protects against. The acute criterion (CMC) covers a short, high exposure: a 1-hour average. The chronic criterion (CCC) covers a long, lower exposure: a 4-day average. Each is a concentration "not to be exceeded more than once every three years on the average" (40 CFR 131.36(c)(2)(ii), eCFR). Because the CCC must hold over a longer period, it is usually equal to or lower than the CMC, and for persistent organochlorines it can be several orders of magnitude lower.
Approach: I used EPA's national recommended aquatic life criteria table and the CMC/CCC definitions in 40 CFR 131.36, EPA's federally promulgated toxics criteria for specific states. EPA's criteria table page gives only the full names of the terms, not their averaging periods.
Definitions (40 CFR 131.36)
| Acute: CMC | Chronic: CCC | |
|---|---|---|
| Name | Criterion Maximum Concentration | Criterion Continuous Concentration |
| Protects against | "acute effects in aquatic life" | "chronic effects in aquatic life" |
| Exposure | "a short period of time (1-hour average)" | "an extended period of time (4 days)" |
| Exceedance frequency | Not more than once every three years on the average | Same |
| Design low flow for streams (the State "shall not use" a less stringent value) | 1Q10 or 1B3 | 7Q10 or 4B3 |
Source for all rows: footnote d to §131.36(b)(1) and §131.36(c)(2)(ii) (eCFR). The two flows mean:
- 1Q10 is the lowest one-day flow expected once in 10 years.
- 7Q10 is the lowest 7-consecutive-day average flow expected once in 10 years.
- 4B3 allows an exceedance "for 4 consecutive days once every 3 years."
How far apart the values are (freshwater, current EPA table)
- Close or equal:
- About an order of magnitude apart:
- Several orders of magnitude apart (persistent organochlorines):
Many pollutants have only one of the two values
- Chronic only:
- Acute only:
Points that apply to the chronic value specifically
- Cadmium: EPA's 2016 freshwater CCC was vacated by the U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona on August 18, 2023. The current recommended value is in EPA's 2001 cadmium update. The 2016 acute value of 1.8 remains in the table [27].
- PFOA and PFOS (2024):
- Endrin: the CCC derivation "did not consider exposure through the diet, which is probably important for aquatic life occupying upper trophic levels" [30].
Older acute values are not true 1-hour averages
- For criteria issued under the 1980 Guidelines, the acute values are "final acute values (FAV) which by the 1980 Guidelines are instantaneous values as contrasted with a CMC which is a one-hour average" (§131.36(b)(1), footnote g).
- For these, EPA's table says that if evaluation uses an averaging period, the acute values "should be divided by 2" to get a value comparable to a 1985-Guidelines CMC [10][16].
Hardness-dependent metals
-
Both values use the same equation form, with separate acute and chronic slopes, intercepts and conversion factors (§131.36(b)(2)):
- CMC = WER exp{mA[ln(hardness)] + bA} × Acute Conversion Factor
- CCC = WER exp{mC[ln(hardness)] + bC} × Chronic Conversion Factor
WER is the water effect ratio, defined in §131.36(c).
-
Example, cadmium conversion factors:
- Acute: CF = 1.136672 − [(ln hardness)(0.041838)]
- Chronic: CF = 1.101672 − [(ln hardness)(0.041838)]
The averaging periods and exceedance frequency come from 40 CFR 131.36, which applies only to the specific states listed in §131.36(d) and is "not a general promulgation of the section 304(a) criteria" (§131.36(a)).
How should I check ammonia, selenium and chloride criteria?
You can't read a single number off EPA's table for all three, and each needs a different check. Chloride is a fixed freshwater pair: 860000 acute and 230000 chronic, from 1988 [31]. Ammonia has to be calculated for your site's pH and temperature. Freshwater selenium is checked mainly against fish tissue, with the water column as a fallback.
Approach: I used EPA's national recommended aquatic life and human health criteria tables, plus EPA's fact sheets for the 2013 freshwater ammonia criteria and the 2016 freshwater selenium criterion. I didn't open the 1989 saltwater ammonia document or the selenium intermittent-exposure equation, so I give no values for those.
Ammonia: calculate it for your conditions
- Table entry: the table lists no single CMC or CCC. It says freshwater criteria (2013) are "ph, temperature and life-stage dependent" and saltwater criteria (1989) are "pH and temperature dependent" [32].
- Reference values (2013 freshwater fact sheet, EPA 820-F-13-013), in mg total ammonia nitrogen (TAN)/L at pH 7 and 20°C (fact sheet):
- Acute: 17 mg TAN/L as a 1-hour average.
- Chronic: 1.9 mg TAN/L as a 30-day average.
- Extra chronic limit: the highest 4-day average within any 30 days should not exceed 2.5 × the chronic value, which is 4.8 mg TAN/L at pH 7 and 20°C.
- Frequency for all three: not exceeded more than once in three years on average.
- Note the 30-day period. The ammonia chronic criterion uses a 30-day average, not the 4-day average in the 40 CFR 131.36 definitions from the last answer.
- How to check:
- Express your data as TAN.
- Pair each sample with its pH and temperature.
- Calculate the criteria for those conditions using the equations and tables in the 2013 criteria document.
- 2018 correction: EPA's ammonia page says the original CMC equation for sites where Oncorhynchus species are absent "was missing parentheses." Use the corrected document.
- Site-specific options: the fact sheet points to EPA's recalculation procedure and spreadsheet for site-specific criteria. It also points to a technical support document on freshwater mussel surveys, for showing whether sensitive mussels are present.
Selenium: check fish tissue first, then water
- Freshwater (2016): the table gives no freshwater number and refers you to the 2016 criterion document for its narrative statement [33].
- The criterion's elements (fact sheet EPA 822-F-16-005, link):
| Element | Value |
|---|---|
| Egg/ovary | 15.1 mg/kg dry weight |
| Whole body | 8.5 mg/kg dry weight |
| Muscle | 11.3 mg/kg dry weight |
| Water, lentic (lakes, still water) | 1.5 µg/L, 30-day average |
| Water, lotic (rivers, flowing water) | 3.1 µg/L, 30-day average |
| Water, intermittent exposure | An equation, not a fixed value |
- Which element governs:
- If egg/ovary concentrations are measured, they supersede all other elements "except in certain situations."
- Whole-body or muscle data supersede the water column values.
- Water column values apply when there are no fish tissue data. Examples given: fish are absent, the habitat can't support fish, or a new discharge hasn't reached steady state between water and fish tissue.
- No separate acute check: it is a chronic criterion only, and EPA expects it to protect aquatic communities "from any potential acute effects."
- 2021 revision: EPA's selenium page notes a correction to footnote 4: water values are "based on dissolved total selenium." Use the 2021 revision document (EPA 822-R-21-006).
- Saltwater (1999): CMC 290 and CCC 71 [33]. Appendix A gives a total-to-dissolved conversion factor of 0.998 for both [34].
- Human health (2002): 170 for water + organism and 4200 for organism only. EPA notes its drinking water MCL "may be more stringent" [35].
Chloride: compare directly, freshwater only
- CMC 860000 and CCC 230000 in the table's µg/L, which is 860 and 230 mg/L, published 1988 [31].
- The table lists no saltwater values and no human health criterion for chloride.
Before you apply any of these: EPA's fact sheets stress that these recommendations "are not rules." They are "not effective under the Clean Water Act until they have been adopted into a state's water quality standards and approved by EPA." For a permit or assessment, the binding number is the one in the relevant state or tribal standard, which may be a site-specific value.