Q.01

What does Canada's CEPA toxic substances list mean?

The CEPA toxic substances list is Schedule 1 to the Canadian Environmental Protection Act, 1999. Being on it is a legal finding that a substance is "toxic" under the Act, and that finding gives the federal government the power to regulate the substance across its life cycle. It is not a hazard label. The test turns on whether the substance is getting into, or may get into, the Canadian environment in amounts that cause harm.

What "toxic" means (section 64) A substance is toxic if it "is entering or may enter the environment in a quantity or concentration or under conditions that":

  • (a) have or may have an immediate or long-term harmful effect on the environment or its biological diversity;
  • (b) constitute or may constitute a danger to the environment on which life depends; or
  • (c) constitute or may constitute a danger in Canada to human life or health [1].

Because the test depends on exposure, a substance with hazardous properties is not automatically "CEPA-toxic," and a substance that is not a classic chemical can still be listed. For example, Part 2 includes "Plastic manufactured items" [2].

How substances get on the list

  1. Assessment. After assessing a substance, the Ministers (Environment and Climate Change Canada and Health Canada) must publish one proposed outcome in the Canada Gazette (s. 77(2)) [3]:
    • no further action;
    • adding it to the separate list of substances "capable of becoming toxic" under s. 75.1;
    • recommending it for Part 1 of Schedule 1; or
    • recommending it for Part 2.
  2. Comment period. Anyone has 60 days to comment on the proposal. The final decision is then published (s. 77(5)-(6)).
  3. Listing order. The Governor in Council (federal Cabinet) "may, if satisfied that a substance is toxic," make an order adding it to Part 1 or 2. It may also delete a substance whose listing "is no longer necessary," which repeals the section 93 regulations made for it (s. 90(1)-(2)) [4].

Part 1 vs Part 2

  • Part 1 (19 entries) is for the highest-concern substances. The Ministers "shall" propose Part 1 if a substance is toxic and meets any one of these (s. 77(3)) [3]:

    • it may have a long-term harmful effect on the environment and is inherently toxic, persistent and bioaccumulative, present mainly because of human activity, and not a naturally occurring radionuclide or inorganic substance;
    • it may endanger human life or health and is carcinogenic, mutagenic or toxic for reproduction; or
    • it is a substance "that poses the highest risk," as defined in regulations.

    Examples on Part 1 are tributyltins [5], hexabromocyclododecane [6] and polychlorinated naphthalenes [7].

  • Part 2 (134 entries) holds all other toxic substances. Examples are the MDI isocyanates [8], chlorhexidine and its salts [9], and 2-ethylhexyl 2-ethylhexanoate [10].

  • What the split changes. For every listed substance, the Ministers "shall give priority to pollution prevention actions." For Part 1 substances specifically, that priority means "the total, partial or conditional prohibition" of activities or releases. They must also consider whether the activity can be done in a way that minimizes or eliminates harm, and whether feasible alternatives exist (s. 90(1.1)-(1.2)) [4].

What listing means in practice

  • Regulations (s. 93). Cabinet may regulate a listed substance on many fronts [11]:

    • release limits;
    • manufacture, use, sale, import and export conditions;
    • concentration limits in products;
    • packaging and labelling;
    • total, partial or conditional prohibitions, including on products that contain or release the substance.
  • Deadline for proposed controls (s. 91). Once a final decision recommends listing, a proposed regulation or control instrument (or a statement naming one under another federal Act) must be published in the Canada Gazette within two years [12].

  • Emergency powers (s. 94). The Minister may make an interim order where immediate action is needed to deal with a significant danger. This applies to a listed substance that is "not adequately regulated," or to an unlisted one believed toxic [13].

  • Spills and releases (s. 95). If a listed substance is released, or likely to be released, in breach of a s. 93 regulation or s. 94 order, the owner and anyone who caused it "shall":

    • notify an enforcement officer and file a written report;
    • take all reasonable measures to prevent the release or mitigate the danger; and
    • make a reasonable effort to notify members of the public who may be affected [14].

    Under s. 96, others may report voluntarily, with confidentiality and protection for employees [15].

Related lists that are often confused with Schedule 1

  • List of substances "capable of becoming toxic" (s. 75.1). This is a separate watch list. A substance must be removed from it once it is added to Schedule 1, and it is published in the Environmental Registry [16].
  • Virtual Elimination List. This is a separate regulatory schedule that sets a level of quantification for each substance on it, such as hexachlorobutadiene and perfluorooctane sulfonate and its salts [17].

Approach: I read the consolidated text of the Act and its regulations as published by Justice Laws Canada, and Environment and Climate Change Canada's published Schedule 1 entries. Both reflect the Act as amended, including the 2023 amendments (S.C. 2023, c. 12) shown in the text.

Q.02

Does listing a substance automatically ban it?

No. Being added to Schedule 1 does not ban a substance by itself. Listing is a finding that the substance is "toxic" under the Act. That finding gives the federal government the power to regulate it. A ban only exists if a separate regulation imposes one, and many listed substances are controlled by limits or conditions rather than banned.

What listing does in law

  • The listing order only adds the substance to the list. Under s. 90(1), the Governor in Council "may, if satisfied that a substance is toxic," make an order adding it to Part 1 or 2 of Schedule 1. The order contains no prohibition [4].
  • A prohibition is one option among many, and the power is discretionary. Section 93(1) says the Governor in Council "may" make regulations for a listed substance. These can cover release limits, concentration limits in products, labelling, disposal and record-keeping. They can also impose "the total, partial or conditional prohibition of the manufacture, use, processing, sale, offering for sale, import or export of the substance" or of products that contain or release it (s. 93(1)(l)-(m)) [11].
  • Two limits on that power (s. 93(3)-(4)) [18]:
    • The Committee must be given an opportunity to advise first.
    • Cabinet "shall not" regulate an aspect of the substance that another federal Act already regulates in a way that gives sufficient protection.

What listing does require: a control measure on a deadline

  • Proposed control within two years. After a final decision recommends listing, the Minister "shall" publish in the Canada Gazette, within two years, either (s. 91(1)) [12]:
    • a proposed regulation or instrument "respecting preventive or control actions"; or
    • a statement naming one to be made under another federal Act.
  • Final control within 18 months after that. Unless a material substantive change is needed, the final regulation or instrument "shall" be made and published within 18 months of the proposal (s. 92(1)) [19].
  • Both deadlines can be suspended. The clocks stop while a board of review established under s. 333 is sitting (ss. 91(7), 92(2)).

So listing guarantees that some control action follows. It does not guarantee that the action is a ban.

Where Part 1 changes the picture For Part 1 substances, the Ministers "shall" give priority to "the total, partial or conditional prohibition of activities in relation to the substance or of releases of the substance into the environment" (s. 90(1.1)). Even so, they "shall" also consider two things (s. 90(1.2)) [4]:

  • whether the activity or release can be carried out in a way that minimizes or eliminates harm; and
  • whether feasible alternatives exist.

Prohibition is therefore the priority for Part 1, not the automatic result. For Part 2 substances, the priority is pollution prevention generally.

What an actual ban looks like The ban is in a separate regulation that names the substances. Under the Prohibition of Certain Toxic Substances Regulations, 2025 (SOR/2025-270), a person "must not manufacture, use, sell or import" a prohibited toxic substance listed in that Regulation's own Schedule 1, or a product containing it (s. 5(1)) [20]. Even this ban has carve-outs:

  • Exceptions: it is "subject to sections 6 to 9" (s. 5(1)).
  • Incidental presence: it does not apply where the substance is incidentally present. A substance counts as incidentally present when it is at or below the concentration set in that Regulation's Schedule 3 (s. 5(2)) [20].
  • Manufactured items in transit: it does not apply to such items passing through Canada between two places outside Canada (s. 4) [21].

This Regulation repealed the Prohibition of Certain Toxic Substances Regulations, 2012 (s. 15) [22].

Other instruments made under the Act take forms other than a general ban, judging by their titles:

  • product-specific prohibitions, such as the Products Containing Mercury Regulations [23];
  • concentration limits, such as the VOC Concentration Limits for Automotive Refinishing Products Regulations [24];
  • limits in specific fuels, such as the Benzene in Gasoline Regulations [25].

In practice: to know whether a listed substance is restricted, look at the regulations made for that substance, not its Schedule 1 entry.

Approach: I read the consolidated CEPA 1999 and the Prohibition of Certain Toxic Substances Regulations, 2025, as published on Justice Laws Canada (current to 30 June 2026 for the 2025 Regulations). I did not check any individual substance's Schedule 1 entry against its regulations; if you name one, I can.

Q.03