Parallel Import for Pesticides in Great Britain
What is parallel import for pesticides in Great Britain?
In Great Britain, parallel import (called "parallel trade" in the law) lets you place a plant protection product on the market under a permit rather than a full authorisation. The product is bought in an EU/EEA country and must be identical in composition to a "reference product" already authorised in GB. GB no longer accepts new parallel trade applications. The only route left was reinstating permits that lapsed after Brexit, and that window has closed. Northern Ireland still takes new applications.
How it works under GB law
- What it does in law: Article 28(2)(e) of assimilated Regulation 1107/2009 says no authorisation is needed for products "for which a parallel trade permit is in force in accordance with Article 52A" [1]. HSE describes the route as bypassing the safety and efficacy evidence a normal application needs, making it "cheaper, quicker and simpler" (HSE).
- Brexit cut-off: permits held at IP completion day "ceased to be valid on 1st January 2023" [2]. HSE set a final sale date of 30 June 2023 and a final use date of 30 June 2024. It says "applications for new parallel trade permits will be considered for Northern Ireland only" (HSE).
- Reinstatement (Article 52A): the holder of a lapsed permit could apply to have it reinstated. The application "must be made no later than 1st April 2024." It had to include proof that the source product is still authorised and on sale in the Member State of origin, photos of the container label, and a declaration of accuracy. HSE "must grant" the application if the conditions are met [2].
- How long a reinstated permit lasts: until whichever comes first: the reference product's authorisation expires, or two years after the date the permit took effect [2].
- Conditions on the product:
- It "must be placed on the market and used only in accordance with the provisions of the authorisation of the reference product."
- The permit counts as an authorisation for withdrawal and amendment under Articles 44 and 45, and can get a grace period under Article 46.
- It can also be withdrawn if the source product's authorisation is withdrawn in the Member State of origin for safety or efficacy reasons.
- The holder must report new information under Article 56(4) [2].
- Offence: Regulation 11 of the Plant Protection Products Regulations 2011 says a person "must not place on the market or use" a product in breach of Article 52A(8) [3].
What the permit and label must carry (HSE reinstated permit conditions):
- The permit names: the holder, the reference product, the Member State of origin, the source product's registration number, and its authorisation holder there.
- The label shows: the holder's and marketing company's name and address, the MAPP number, and the source product's batch number and production date. Instructions and classification must match the reference product, with no extra claims.
- Records: purchases, batches, storage and sales must be kept for at least 5 years.
- Packaging: must be the same as or equivalent to the reference product's. Repackaging is allowed if it doesn't affect safety or efficacy. Returnable or refillable containers are not allowed.
On the Pesticides Register today
- 26 "Great Britain Only" entries are flagged as parallel import. One is Triumph Cs (MAPP 20946), lambda-cyhalothrin, first authorised 23/04/2024, expiry 30/10/2027 [4].
- 157 "Northern Ireland Only" entries are flagged the same way. An example is Zulkon (MAPP 20399) [5].
- Triumph Cs's entry gives its authorisation level as "Standard Approval", not a permit. So a parallel-import flag on its own doesn't tell you whether an entry is an Article 52A permit.
Approach: I read the current GB text of the Plant Protection Products Regulations 2011 and assimilated Regulation 1107/2009, the HSE Pesticides Register of authorised products, and HSE's guidance pages on parallel trade. The GB text of Article 52 itself shows only its heading, so the Brexit-era rules come from Article 52A and HSE's guidance.
How is it different from mutual recognition?
The two routes do different jobs. Mutual recognition gets you a new authorisation of your own, granted on the strength of another authority's assessment of the same product. Parallel trade gives you no authorisation at all: it is a permit to sell an identical imported product under someone else's GB authorisation (the "reference product"). In current GB law, mutual recognition also works differently from the EU version. It now runs between the competent authorities for England, Wales and Scotland, not between EU Member States.
| Mutual recognition (Articles 42A-42C) | Parallel trade (Article 52A) | |
|---|---|---|
| What you get | An authorisation. The authority "must authorise the plant protection product concerned under the same conditions as the reference competent authority" [6] | A permit, which is an exemption from needing an authorisation under Article 28(2)(e) [1] |
| What it starts from | A product authorised under Article 29 by a "reference competent authority" [7]. These are the Secretary of State (England), the Welsh Ministers and the Scottish Ministers [8] | A product authorised in an EU/EEA "Member State of origin" that is "identical in composition" to a UK-authorised reference product [2] |
| Who can apply | The authorisation holder. An official or scientific body, or a professional agricultural organisation, can also apply with the holder's consent, or with the authority's consent on public-interest grounds if the holder refuses. These bodies must show the use is of general interest [7] | Only the person who held an original permit that lapsed on 1 January 2023, applying no later than 1 April 2024 [2] |
| Scope | "The same plant protection product, the same use and under comparable agricultural practices" in another constituent territory [7] | The product "must be placed on the market and used only in accordance with the provisions of the authorisation of the reference product" [2] |
| What you submit | A copy of the reference authorisation, a formal statement that the product is identical, the full or summary Article 33(3) dossier if requested, and the reference authority's assessment report. The decision is due "within 120 days" [9] | Duplicates of the original permit application, proof the source product is still authorised and on sale, container photos, label confirmation and a declaration. No safety or efficacy dossier [2] |
| Authority's discretion | Discretion only when the product contains a candidate for substitution or an Article 4(7) substance. Paragraphs 1 and 2 do not apply where Article 36(3) applies [6]. Article 36(3) lets an authority impose conditions, or refuse if it has "substantiated reasons" based on its specific environmental or agricultural circumstances [10] | The authority "must grant" the application if the conditions are met [2] |
| How long it lasts | It is a full authorisation in its own right | Until the reference product's authorisation expires, or two years after the permit takes effect, whichever comes first [2] |
When mutual recognition is not available
Under Article 42A(4), you cannot apply if any of these is true in the receiving territory [7]:
- An active substance, safener or synergist is not approved there.
- The substance's approval conditions are incompatible with the product, or its technical specification is not equivalent.
- A co-formulant is on that territory's unacceptable co-formulants register.
- The data requirements, uniform principles or Article 77 guidance are not the same in both territories.
Minor uses
Article 51(7) lets the bodies listed in Article 51(1) apply for minor uses under Article 42A. The receiving authority must authorise those uses under Article 42B, provided it also considers them minor [11].
What happened to the EU route
Article 40, the EU mutual recognition article, is omitted from the GB text [12]. Articles 41 and 42 remain only for applications made under Article 40 "as it had effect immediately before IP completion day" [13][14]. So an authorisation granted in an EU Member State no longer gives you a mutual recognition route into GB. Parallel trade is likewise closed to new GB applicants.
The original recitals of Regulation 1107/2009, still printed in the GB text, sum up the policy difference. Mutual recognition exists "to avoid any duplication of work" by accepting another authority's authorisation where conditions are comparable. Parallel trade is "a simplified procedure" for identical products already authorised elsewhere [15].
Approach: I read the current GB text of assimilated Regulation 1107/2009: Articles 3A, 28, 36, 40-42C, 51 and 52A. I did not look at HSE's operational guidance on how GB mutual recognition applications are handled in practice.