Q.01

What is Red 40 Lake?

Red 40 Lake (FD&C Red No. 40 Lake) is the insoluble pigment form of the synthetic azo dye FD&C Red No. 40 (Allura Red AC, E129). FDA defines lakes as "insoluble pigments formed by chemically reacting water-soluble straight colors with precipitants and substrata" [1]. Under US law it is not a separate additive: 21 CFR 74.340 says "the listing of this color additive includes lakes prepared as described in § 82.51" [2].

Approach: I checked FDA's Regulatory Status of Color Additives inventory and 21 CFR Part 74. Part 82, which sets out how lakes are made, is not in the datasets, so I read 21 CFR 82.51 on eCFR.

What it is chemically

  • The parent dye: FD&C Red No. 40 "is principally the disodium salt of 6-hydroxy-5-[(2-methoxy-5-methyl-4-sulfophenyl)azo]-2-naphthalenesulfonic acid" [3]. Its CAS number is 25956-17-6. Other names include Allura Red AC, C.I. 16035 and Food Red 17 [1].
  • How the lake is made: under 21 CFR 82.51, the certified water-soluble dye is combined with aluminum or calcium to form a salt. That salt is then spread onto a base of alumina. The dye must already be certified.
  • Purity limits: soluble chlorides and sulfates (as sodium salts) not more than 2.0 percent; HCl-insoluble inorganic matter not more than 0.5 percent.
  • Naming: the name is built from the color name, the metal used, and the word "Lake". So the aluminum version is "FD&C Red No. 40 Aluminum Lake", which is the form usually found on labels.
  • Why use a lake: the dye dissolves in water, but the lake does not. It colors food by being spread through it as fine particles, which suits fatty or low-moisture products, coatings, tablets and cosmetics.

US regulatory status

  • Listing: permanently listed, and certification is required. It is permitted in foods, drugs and cosmetics [1].
  • How this differs from most lakes: FDA notes that most lakes are only provisionally listed under 21 CFR 81.1. In contrast, "All FD&C Red No. 40 lakes are permanently listed under 21 CFR 74.340 (food), 74.1340 (drugs), and 74.2340 (cosmetics)." The rule for the lakes was published at 36 FR 23552 on 10 December 1971 [1].
  • Batch certification: "All batches of FD&C Red No. 40 and lakes thereof shall be certified in accordance with regulations in part 80" [4].
  • Labeling: the label of the color, and of any lakes or mixtures made from it, "shall conform to the requirements of § 70.25" [5].
  • Food use: it "may be safely used for coloring foods (including dietary supplements) generally in amounts consistent with good manufacturing practice." It may not be used in foods with a standard of identity unless that standard authorizes added color [6].
  • Cosmetics and eye area: permitted in cosmetics generally, including lakes. It must not be exposed to oxidizing or reducing agents that could affect the color. Use in drugs and cosmetics for the eye area is allowed, and this includes the aluminum lake [1].

FDA's record gives the EU number as E129 [1]. I did not check the EU or other non-US rules for the lake form. I can do that next if you need it.

Q.02

How is it regulated in food?

Red 40 Lake is regulated differently in each jurisdiction. In the US it is covered by the same listing as FD&C Red No. 40: it is permitted in food generally at good manufacturing practice (GMP) levels, every batch must be certified, and labels must name it as "Red 40 Lake". In the EU, the aluminium lake of E129 may only be used in the food categories where Annex II explicitly sets a limit for aluminium from lakes. In other categories only the dye itself may be used, and every food containing E129 must carry the children's activity-and-attention warning.

Approach: I checked these sources:

  • US: 21 CFR Part 74, 21 CFR Part 101 and FDA's announcements.
  • EU: the consolidated Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008.
  • Elsewhere: the GB approved E-numbers list, Health Canada's List of Permitted Colouring Agents, Japan's designated additives list and use standards, ANVISA's additives panel, South Africa's R1008/1996 and FSANZ's comparison table.
  • Not covered: the EU purity specifications (Regulation 231/2012), Codex GSFA, India and Korea are not in the datasets I can search.

United States (federal)

  • Covered by the dye's listing: lakes are included in the listing for FD&C Red No. 40 if they are made under § 82.51 and meet its specification and labelling rules [2].
  • Uses: it "may be safely used for coloring foods (including dietary supplements) generally in amounts consistent with good manufacturing practice". It may not be used in foods that have a standard of identity unless that standard authorizes added color [6].
  • Mixtures: colour mixtures for food may contain only diluents listed in Part 73 [7].
  • Certification: "All batches of FD&C Red No. 40 and lakes thereof shall be certified" under Part 80 [4].
  • Ingredient list (21 CFR 101.22(k)(1)): the "FD&C" prefix and "No." may be dropped, "but the term 'Lake' shall be included", so the declaration is "Red 40 Lake" [8].
  • Federal phase-out (not binding): on 22 April 2025 FDA announced it was "working with industry to eliminate" six synthetic dyes, including FD&C Red No. 40, "from the food supply by the end of next year" (FDA). This is a cooperative effort with industry. It does not change the 21 CFR listing above.

US states

  • West Virginia: HB 2354 was signed on 24 March 2025 and covers Red Dye No. 40 (Governor of West Virginia):
    • it is banned in school nutrition programme meals from 1 August 2025;
    • it "must not be contained in food items for sale in the state" from 1 January 2028.
  • California: AB 2316 is the school-food dye bill. I could not open the official bill page, so I could not confirm its final status or dates.

European Union (Regulation 1333/2008, consolidated text)

Whether the lake is allowed at all. E129 Allura Red AC is in Table 3, "Colours which may be used in the form of lakes" [9]. However, since 1 August 2014 aluminium lakes are authorised "only in those food categories where provisions on maximum limits on aluminium coming from lakes are explicitly stated in Part E" [10].

How E129 is authorised. Most uses come through Group III, "Food colours with combined maximum limit" [11]. E129 also has 10 entries of its own, and none of them carries an aluminium-lake provision. They cover:

  • red-fruit preserves at 200 mg/kg [12];
  • breakfast sausages and burger meat at 25 mg/kg [13];
  • health marking on fresh meat at quantum satis [14].

Group III categories with an "all aluminium lakes" limit (current entries from 1 August 2014). These are the categories where the E129 lake can be used:

CategoryGroup III maxAluminium from all lakes
01.4 Flavoured fermented milk15015 mg/kg [15]
05.2 Other confectionery300 (candied fruit 200)70 mg/kg; microsweets 40 [16][17]
05.3 Chewing gum300300 mg/kg [18]
05.4 Decorations, coatings (500), fillings (300)as stated300 mg/kg [19][20]
12.2.2 Seasonings500120 mg/kg [21]
14.1.4 Flavoured drinks10015 mg/kg [22]
15.1 Snacks200 extruded / 100 other30 mg/kg [23][24]
16 Desserts15015 mg/kg [25]
17.1 Solid food supplements300150 mg/kg [26]

All maximum levels are in mg/kg. In several categories the amounts of E122 and E155 are each capped at 50 mg/kg (footnote 25).

Edible ices (03): unclear. The Group III entry has no lake footnote [27]. The only "all aluminium lakes" limit for the category (30 mg/kg) sits on the Group II entry [28]. Whether that limit covers E129 lake is not stated.

Categories where only carmine lakes are allowed ("No other aluminium lakes may be used"):

  • 07.2 Fine bakery wares [29]
  • 01.7.3 Edible cheese rind [30]
  • 08.3.3 Meat casings and coatings [31]
  • 09.2 Surimi [32]
  • 09.3 Fish roe [33]
  • 12.6 Sauces [34]
  • 13.2 Foods for special medical purposes [35]
  • 14.2.6, 14.2.7.3 and 14.2.8 Alcoholic drinks [36]

Here the E129 dye may be used but the E129 lake may not.

Categories where the Group III entry has no lake provision. These include mustard [37], soups [38], liquid supplements [39] and meal replacements [40]. Under the Part A rule, only the dye form can be used in these.

Carry-over. Colours may not be present through carry-over in the foods listed in Part A Table 2, which include bread, pasta, unflavoured dairy and tomato products [41].

Warning label. Under Article 24, the labelling of foods containing Annex V colours "shall include" extra information [42]. For Allura red (E 129) the wording is "'name or E number of the colour(s)': may have an adverse effect on activity and attention in children". There are two exceptions: health or other marking on meat or decorative colouring on eggshells, and beverages over 1.2% alcohol by volume [43].

Other jurisdictions

  • Great Britain: E129 Allura Red AC is on the approved colours list [44]. The GB conditions of use, including any rules on lakes, are not in the datasets.
  • Canada: Allura Red is item A.2 of List 3 (colouring agents), with 11 food-use entries. For example:
    • in unstandardized foods, at most 300 ppm singly or combined with other listed synthetic colours, with brilliant blue FCF and fast green FCF capped at 100 ppm [45];
    • lumpfish caviar 1,300 ppm [46];
    • fruit-flavoured beer 10 ppm [47].
    • Allura Red carries a footnote (*) whose text I could not read, so I could not confirm how Canada treats its lakes.
  • Japan: it is designated additive No. 218, "Food Red No.40 (Allura Red AC) and its Aluminum Lake" [48]. Under the use standards (2026-04-07 edition) it is "Not permitted in" a list of foods, including fresh fish and shellfish, meat, vegetables, legumes, noodles, soy sauce, miso, marmalade, tea leaves and sponge cakes [49].
  • Brazil: ANVISA's panel lists "Vermelho allura AC" with category-specific limits, for example:
    • 300 mg/kg in 05.2 [50];
    • 500 mg/kg in 13.4, but not in products whose name includes "tomate" [51].
    • The entries I read do not mention lakes.
  • South Africa (R1008/1996): Allura red AC is in Annexure V Table 2, for use singly or in combination up to the Table 3 maximum levels [52]. On raw meat and eggshells it is allowed "For marking only" [53]. A note says "Aluminium lacquer colourants prepared from colorants mentioned in this Annex are Authorized" [54].
  • Australia/New Zealand: FSANZ's comparison table shows INS 129 permitted in the US (§74.340) and the EU (1333/2008) [55]. The Food Standards Code permissions themselves are not in the datasets.
Q.03

What about UK labels?

I could only partly confirm the UK label rules. GOV.UK states which law applies where: in England and Wales it is the "assimilated Regulation (EU) 1333/2008", and in Northern Ireland it is the EU Regulation (EU) 1333/2008 itself. The EU text I read requires a warning on foods containing E129 and sets how additives are named in the ingredients list. I could not open the GB-assimilated versions of those provisions, so I can't confirm the exact wording that applies in Great Britain.

Approach: I checked the GB approved additives list, the GOV.UK "Approved additives and E numbers" guidance (published 25 June 2026), and the current EU texts of Regulation 1333/2008 and Regulation 1169/2011 (food information to consumers). I tried to open the GB-assimilated texts on legislation.gov.uk and the FSA's food additives page, but neither returned any text.

What is confirmed for the UK

  • Approval: E129 Allura Red AC is on the GB approved list as a colour [44].
  • Which law applies where: the GOV.UK guidance names the assimilated Regulation 1333/2008 for England and Wales, and the EU Regulation 1333/2008 for Northern Ireland. It shows the two systems can differ. For example, E171 titanium dioxide is no longer permitted in food made in Northern Ireland, and E960d is authorised in Northern Ireland but not in GB.
  • Not covered by that guidance: it says nothing about how additives are labelled, does not mention the colours warning, and has no rules on lakes.

What the EU text says (this applies in Northern Ireland, according to the GOV.UK statement above)

  • Warning: labels of foods containing the colours listed in Annex V "shall include" extra information [42]. For Allura red (E 129), the wording is "'name or E number of the colour(s)': may have an adverse effect on activity and attention in children". There are two exceptions: health or other marking on meat and decorative colouring on eggshells, and beverages over 1.2% alcohol by volume [43].
  • Name in the ingredients list: additives "must be designated by the name of that category, followed by their specific name or, if appropriate, E number". "Colour" is one of the listed categories [56]. The ingredients list "shall" carry a heading that includes the word "ingredients" [57].
  • Additives can't be dropped from the list: in compound ingredients that make up less than 2% of the product, a breakdown of ingredients is normally optional, but that exemption "shall not apply to food additives", subject to Article 20(a) to (d) [58].

Points for a US product going to the UK

  • The US "Red 40 Lake" wording comes from 21 CFR 101.22(k), which is a US rule only. Nothing I found says UK law accepts it.
  • None of the UK or EU texts I read gives a separate way to name the lake form on the label.
  • Before printing GB labels, the wording to confirm is in the assimilated texts that apply in England and Wales: Article 24 and Annex V of Regulation 1333/2008, and Annex VII of Regulation 1169/2011. I could not open these, and I did not find out which text governs labelling in Scotland. Using a lake in a UK product also depends on the GB conditions of use, including any rules on aluminium lakes, which are not in the datasets I can search.
Q.04